Okay, thank you for your quick response! Here are the stats:
A small island that has all rabbitholes, some amount of homes (10-20, doesn't matter if they are EA created)
Coastal feel (Palm trees, beaches, etc.)
2/3 of homes be inhabited (Once again, doesn't matter if they are EA created. Note: Try to populate the larger homes)
30-50 Sims would be a nice small amount to see some activity
No clubs OR lounges, just one park would be nice.
All fish, Seed spawners* (Seed spawners optional, I just want it to feel "complete"
...I think that covers it! Oh yeah: try to create a good mix of starters, intermediate, and those 400,000 homes most people just cheat to get.
One more thing: If you are allowed to name islands in Create-A-World, the name Coastal Cove would be nice.