I just got Supernatural and haven't logged a lot of time in yet, but I have to say, I'm really enjoying it. I had rejected it for Seasons, but the talk of new plants and bees got my interest, so I finally succumbed and purchased it and am glad I did!
I love the town, which is very beautiful. My favorite town before this had been Sunset Valley, and this reminds me of SV some, but is more beautiful and intriguing, I think. Right now, I'm just enjoying exploring the town.
Like other people, I also love the new plants and am really enjoying gathering them and the beekeeping too. I also really like the fairies, and have only played as a fairy so far.
I haven't even had trouble with the zombies yet, but I imagine I will....just haven't played long enough yet to hit the full moon. I like the ghosts, though--they're fun, and I like that there is an option to ask them "how they kicked the bucket"!
I'm really glad I got this EP!