Which male sim townie has the best genetics?

[Vanillin]

Personally, I'm a fan of Sherman Bagley, he makes good kids, as does Billy Caspian, both from Riverview. Conner and Cyclone are my favourites in Sunset Valley.

Sherman is a bomb, his children are almost always pretty. Odin Crosby also seems to have good genes, his children with Heather (and other NPCs) are always gorgeous. I haven't tried Billy Caspian, thanks for pointing him out.
I tried Tom Shallow and his genetics are quite well. His children are never that good looking but they're quite pretty.
Edit: Also tested Billy Caspian. His son looks good but can't say the same for his unfortunate daughter who looks just like him.

[sammymcgoff]

Sorry tp bump this up again, but which guy sim has the best genes in Moonlight Falls. I got Supernatural yesterday, and I married my Sim to Dwayne Wolff, so I planning to make them have kids.

[Snufflesxx]

Who in Twinbrookian would you recommend so for producing good genetics? I know most of them are, well, quite ugly, but who can produce some nice offspring?

[Wiry]

Who in Twinbrookian would you recommend so for producing good genetics? I know most of them are, well, quite ugly, but who can produce some nice offspring?

Goodwin Goode is the only non hated male there xD

[Snufflesxx]

Just looked Goodwin up on Sims 3 Wiki - he's not a bad looking chap! I like him. Thanks, Wiry 

[sammymcgoff]

Snuffles, if you let your sim breed with Phoenix Prudence, just hope that any daughters aren't carbon copies of him! My simself ans two daughters with him, and the older one looks just like him, and she's very unique looking . Even though she's only a child, she has a very strong jawline, droopy looking eyes and a pointy nose, which look alright on him, but not so good on her.

[Abbie]

Grady Elfman in Sunset Valley (Hard to get at first as he's a maid), can give your female sims cute nooboos. The only problem he has that he has only four traits, and one of them is Kleptomaniac. You can keep it like that or change him

[Vinyl]

Ritchie Striker from Bridgeport makes very expressive children (and cute too!).  In my experience his eyes dominate a bloodline as much as the infamous Steel lips.  Here's a couple of shots from eight generations of his descendents.  Other than Sherman Bagley marrying Ritchie's daughter, all of the genetics through the generations were randomly generated game sims.


Mother on the right, daughter on the left.  Her eyes are Ritchie's through and through.  It gives a serene quality to the expression at rest, but that disappears when the emotions start showing!


Same kid, much different expression.


Ritchie's great-granddaughter, still the same eyes.  Never seen a sim able to 'well up' with emotion before, but she was a champ at it thanks to his genes.


Ritchie's grandson and great-great-great-granddaughter.  Her eye shape was a bit different by that point, but they were still Ritchie large.


If the daughter is generation one, this guy is generation eight.  The eyes are still large and still have that hint of droop at the corners.

[Shadowkeepernoir]

I'm particular to Jon Lessen of Riverview, though I did learn not to dilly dally. He married my founder and aged up to elder very quickly (I spent a good week at least chasing other people before I met him). He passed away before I could level him up to 10 charisma, there by missing his LTW. The kids (all girls) were stunning, only one of the three got his jaw, and with a fuller hairstyle she wore it well. I will say though he is one of the worst characters for disturbing babies. He loves them and he's great with them, but hes also bad for waking them up.

[sammymcgoff]

I know people say that Goodwin Goode and the Rackets are the only hope for Twinbrook in terms of good genetics, but I must say I was pleasantly surprised at how good Robert Castor's genes are. He had 6 sons with my Simself and all of them were very handsome when they aged up. One of them inherited his jaw, which looked awkward on the poor guy as a toddler and child, but one he hit teen, the jaw looked just fine on him. And also, Robert may occasionally roll the have a child wish, despite not having the family oriented trait.

[RaiaDraconis]

I know people say that Goodwin Goode and the Rackets are the only hope for Twinbrook in terms of good genetics, but I must say I was pleasantly surprised at how good Robert Castor's genes are. He had 6 sons with my Simself and all of them were very handsome when they aged up. One of them inherited his jaw, which looked awkward on the poor guy as a toddler and child, but one he hit teen, the jaw looked just fine on him. And also, Robert may occasionally roll the have a child wish, despite not having the family oriented trait.

I'm also going to toss out Shamus Drudge as well. As far as Twinbrook men go he is actually rather handsome, and I've seen several kids of his with Eva that are quite lovely. And frankly, I love his hair color.

[sammymcgoff]

In Barnacle Bay, be careful if you use Jeff Smith - his kid in my 100 Baby Challenge ended up looking like this  The poor lad is only a teen.

[_Annika_]

A good way to test the genetics is to open a new different game, and use the edit in CAS cheat. You can age sims up or down, and change their gender. So far, if my sim marries a male resident, then has a daughter, the daughter looks like the father. So I take each of the men into CAS, age them down if necessary, and change their gender to see what they look like. Or, you could use edit in CAS, then save them to the sim bin. Go back to edit town and use CAH to try different combinations with your sim and the saved sim.

[Jamie]

What men have good genetics in Moonlight Falls? I don't mind if they're teens/children, I can wait!  Also, I'd prefer vampires but any male sim is good.

[kellie13]

I'm also going to toss out Shamus Drudge as well. As far as Twinbrook men go he is actually rather handsome, and I've seen several kids of his with Eva that are quite lovely. And frankly, I love his hair color.

I'll second Shamus! Give him a new hairdo and he's quite the looker. His son looked just like him, although died as a YA due to electrocution. His ghost moved in with his wife though and they had a daughter, not a ghost, who is the most beautiful of all my sims I believe. Her son is also extremely handsome, though Shamus doesn't seem to be in there. Great genes though!