I asked Carl about this thread the day it was started because, technically, it's not about Sims 3 and I didn't know if it should be allowed. He said that because it's also comparing Sims 1 and 2 to Sims 3, it's ok for it to stay. However, if it were discussing something specific to game play issues with Sims 1 and 2 and never even mentioned Sims 3, it would be a different story.
What I would like for everyone to understand is that we're not trying to be strict for strictness' sake. This Forum is a
Sims 3 forum. It's not a Sims 2 or a Medieval forum. It's here to discuss Sims 3 only. While Sims 2 and Medieval were made by the same company, they are different games and not related to Sims 3 in any way. It would be like allowing a topic for Rift or Diablo 3. Those games aren't Sims 3 and don't belong here.
I just want everyone to understand that we must have a place to draw the line, and the line is drawn at Sims 3. Now that we have the new Babble Board, I agree that this topic belongs there. If anyone would like to discuss any of this further, you're welcome to send me a private message so that we don't keep this thread off topic.