I have been wondering if a sim with the "neat" trait would clean and maintain cleanliness of the house as good as or better than an average butler. I would like to know if you have tested or seen the outcome.
I am not against using a butler and i have already installed the pack. And i think it's cool to have a butler in the house. But I have fired many butlers due to I feel that they (some of them) don't perform well enough, for example one of them I ordered to cook a meal, he took a raw material set from the refrigerator then he just put it on the floor and walked out to the backyard doing nothing, I repeated the same order then he repeated the same action and he got fired immediately.
Some other butlers I fired because I found out that they had the "Lazy" and "Mean" traits. The current one is pending my decision because she is terrible at playing piano like zero piano skill.
So i have come to think that if i create a sim with the "neat" trait and use the cheat codes to give her some skills and housekeeping traits similar to a butler, and let that sim live in my house instead of the butler, would that sim perform as good as a butler in housekeeping ? (Automatically without having to direct the sim to do). Apart from the fact that a user created sim can do everything that a butler cannot (when directed).