Hi Playalot, the fruit he was using was perfect and the quality of the nectar was perfect, but the combination of the fruit was the telling factor. Using 5/5 Pomegranate/Life fruit, the nectar was only "good" or less. As I said, when I decreased the number of Pomegranates to 1 and 9 Life Fruit, the quality jumped up to "Amazing." So the fruit combinations also work towards the quality (for lack of better words) of the nectar.