Well, a teenage sim I'm playing went to prom and came back with a romantic interest, and the relation bar nearly maxed out. A while later, he gets a wish to be that sim's Good Friend. The problem is, his relationship with this girl is already maxed out, and was nearly so when he popped the wish. Is the wish just bugged, and unfulfillable? Is this the game's way of saying they should just be friends, and that'll fix it (Which is cool by me; she's no catch).