I was playing a game, and realized that sometimes the value of the goods that my Sim baked using the cupcake factory were below those listed in the guide. At first I thought it was because of marketable, but then Nutella suggested that maybe the values in the guide were out of date. I decided to test this theory on a Sim without marketable, and found that my values were different than the guide values. This could be due to patches, or it could be other reasons. I found that there is some random variation for anything made by the cupcake factory even without the marketable trait, and that the skill level of the Sim matters. I think that the values for the chart before were all gotten at skill level 10, but if your Sim is at a lower level this can make a big difference.
I went through and tested the values for both cupcakes and baked goods, testing everything twice and coming up with an average. I tested both at the minimum level required to make the good (the first number), and at level 10 (the second number). All ingredients used for the baked goods were normal quality. I found that if I was at the minimum required level to make a baked good and it took ingredients, it initially made good quality, which was undesirable and also not possible to sell. I had my Sim garnish the good up to excellent quality, but I think the sell value was still based on good quality, since it always sold for less than expected for excellent quality. The quality was always initially excellent if the good required ingredients, but my Sim was above the minimum level required to make it. The italicized values are ones that were initially good quality, but garnished to excellent.
Here are the values I got. All of these values were gotten using the sell to bakery interaction.
Baking
Plain Muffins 12, 28
Doughnut Holes 11.5, 27.5
Plain Doughnuts 10, 30
Cream Tarts 18, 38
Glazed Doghnuts 15.5, 34
Powdered Doughnuts 15.5, 37
Fruit Tarts 12.5, 49.5
Fruit Muffins 13, 45
Exotic Fruit Tarts 21, 67
Chocolate Doughnuts 38, 63
Mixed Fruit Tarts 20, 66
Jelly Filled Doughnuts 33, 83.5
Cream Filled Doughnuts 60, 76.5
Plain Scones 56, 82
Fruit Scones 48.5, 115.5
Salmon Croquettes 99, 121.5
Soft Shell Crab Cakes 135.5, 153
Profiteroles 117, 159.5
Croissants 118.5, 148.5
Chocolate Biscotti 211.5, 222
Bacon Wrapped Doughnuts 313, 321
Cereal Topped Doughnuts 304, 316
Creme Brulee 291, 311
Berry Macaroons 270.5, 291.5
Voodoo Doll Doughnuts 277, 335
Eclairs 510.5
Alien Fruit Tarts 281
Cupcakes
classic vanilla 4, 8.5
Minty Mocha 5, 11.5
Carrot Cake Cupcakes 12, 22
Butterscotchman 24.5, 44
Strawberry Fizzy 42, 57.5
Red Velvet 66.5, 77
Super Chocolate Tummers Bomb 132, 150
The Baconing 251, 256
