I played Sunset Valley right after Supernatural came out. A lot of my favorite townies that had previously turned into vamps were now other occults. Nancy Landgraab, Christopher Steel, Cyclone Sword, Leighton Sekemoto were all witches. Hank Goddard, Justine Keaton, Boyd Wainwright, Blair Wainwright and Dustin Langerak are all werewolves. Emma Hatch, Vita Alto, Simis Bachelor, Jocasta Bachelor, Beau Andrews were all fairies.
It was actually fun to see what various people became. It's actually a small bit of enjoyment now to go to a town I know really well and see who becomes what since it's so random.